HomeEconomyEconomist Dele Oye Rejects $10bn Annual Loss Claim on Reserves
spot_img

Economist Dele Oye Rejects $10bn Annual Loss Claim on Reserves

Date:

Claims that Nigeria loses more than $10 billion yearly by holding foreign reserves are built on shaky arithmetic, according to Dele Oye, chairman of the Alliance for Economic Research and Ethics (AERE), who says the country needs a transparent, country-specific answer to how much its buffers actually cost.

Oye made the argument in a policy essay dated October 18, 2026, responding to comments by Mustafa Chike-Obi, former Fidelity Bank chairman and former Managing Director of the Asset Management Corporation of Nigeria (AMCON) .

Chike-Obi had argued that reserves earned about 3% annually while the cost of naira funds used to support them was around 20%. That gap, he said, created a potential 17-percentage-point annual loss if the exchange rate stayed unchanged .

Oye, a lawyer and former President of the Nigerian Association of Chambers of Commerce, Industry, Mines and Agriculture (NACCIMA), said the calculation carries an important economic point but cannot stand as an accurate loss figure without more evidence.

Why the Interest-Rate Gap Doesn't Add Up

The flaw, Oye explained, is that the naira rate and the dollar return reflect different currencies, risks and financing arrangements.

A proper comparison would have to account for exchange-rate movements, hedging costs, instrument maturities and the actual yields on the liabilities used to finance or sterilise reserves.

“The useful conclusion is therefore neither that reserves are free nor that Nigeria is burning US$10 billion every year. The useful conclusion is harder and more valuable: Nigeria needs a transparent, country-specific answer to the question, adequate for what, against which shocks, and at what marginal cost?” he said .

Oye argued that reserves are not ordinary savings to be judged by interest earned.

They are protection against shocks that could destabilise the economy, including falling oil receipts, retreating foreign investment and external borrowing constraints.

“An insurance policy appears wasteful in calm weather because the storm has not yet arrived,” he said.

“The question is never whether insurance earns as much as risk capital in fair weather. The question is whether the country can survive the event for which the insurance exists.”

Gross Reserves Are Not Free Cash

Oye acknowledged that Nigeria’s reserve position has improved. However, he warned that the headline figure must be read alongside what is readily available, existing foreign obligations and exposure to shocks.

He noted that reserves include separate portions attributable to the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), the federal government and the federation.

The balance must also be examined alongside liquid assets, encumbered funds and net international reserves .

“A large gross balance can therefore be a sign of improved resilience without being freely spendable national cash,” he said.

Oye also cautioned against proposals to automatically move reserves above a set threshold into a development fund or routine debt repayment. Such a move, he said, would blur the line between monetary reserves and fiscal savings.

“The federal budget needs revenue, borrowing authority and fiscal institutions. The CBN needs a reserve buffer and a balance sheet fit for monetary stability. These are related national accounts, but they are not the same wallet,” he said.

A Five-Point Plan for Better Reserve Management

Oye proposed five reforms to make Nigeria’s external position more transparent and less costly.

First, he called on the CBN to publish a quarterly reserve adequacy dashboard.

It should show gross reserves, liquid reserves, blocked amounts, net international reserves, months of prospective imports, short-term external debt coverage and the IMF’s reserve adequacy metric.

Second, he advocated a publicly explained reserve adequacy range rather than a rigid target, reflecting import needs, debt maturities, the exchange-rate regime and exposure to shocks.

Third, he asked authorities to reduce dependence on expensive, short-term foreign investment attracted by high yields, since more stable domestic financing would lower the risk of sudden outflows.

Fourth, he called for a credible exchange-rate framework that lets the naira adjust to market conditions while the CBN intervenes only to contain disorderly moves.

Finally, he backed diversification of the reserve portfolio, citing the CBN’s Domestic Gold Purchase Programme as strategically important, though he acknowledged gold carries its own price and liquidity risks.

He also called for stronger formal channels for remittances, export proceeds and long-term investment.

Reserves built on sustainable foreign-exchange earnings, he said, would be more resilient than those dependent on reversible portfolio inflows.

Oye contrasted the statutory import-cover condition with the International Monetary Fund’s (IMF) projection of about 9.7 months of prospective import cover for Nigeria in 2026, while noting the two measures may not use identical bases.

“Mr. Chike-Obi is right to puncture the superstition that a larger reserve headline automatically means a richer Nigeria. But the opposite superstition is equally dangerous. The reserve balance is not a lazy dollar pile, and the MPR is not a universal invoice for holding it,” he said.

2 COMMENTS

guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Dike
First Talker
first_talker
Points: 7785
29 days ago

Humm

Rovafenivid
Platinum
First Talker
first_talker
Points: 64189
29 days ago

All these plans is not really the issue, the implementation as well as the sustainability of it even when you are not in office is what we need now as a people, white coated horses is not the main thing now, we need more and we deserve more.

spot_img

Related articles:

House of Reps Opens Probe Into 22 States Over Unpaid Pensions

The House of Representatives has ordered an investigation into 22 states over unpaid pensions, following reports that thousands of retirees face years of arrears and hardship.

Cooking Gas Price Rises 14% to ₦1,600/kg Amid Supply Shortage

Cooking gas now sells for ₦1,600 per kilogramme, up 14% from October. NALPGAM says supply cannot match demand, while experts call for infrastructure subsidies instead of price controls.

Nigeria’s Inflation Falls to 14.06% as Food Prices Stay High

Nigeria's inflation rate declined to 14.06% in October, marking another monthly improvement. However, rising monthly inflation and persistent food costs continue to affect household spending.

$700 Shipping Surcharge Raises Import Costs for Businesses

Nigerian importers face an additional $700 peak-season shipping charge per container on qualifying shipments from China, following a new CMA CGM tariff effective November 1.

Tinubu Begins $3.5bn Bakassi Seaport, to Break Lagos Monopoly

President Tinubu has opened the $3.5 billion Bakassi Deep Seaport in Cross River, dismissing rumours that Lagos interests opposed it and projecting $44 billion in annual blue economy earnings.

Latest News:

Jonathan’s Second Wife Marks 50th Birthday with a Book Launch

Ayima Lott-Jonathan, wife of former President Goodluck Jonathan, will launch her memoir, 'Gold Dust', on November 19. The book explores patience, motherhood, and purposeful service.

WAEC Announce Hybrid CBT and Paper Exams, Begins WASSCE Registration

WAEC has opened registration for the 2027 WASSCE and confirmed a hybrid format. Candidates will answer objective questions on computers while essay and practical papers remain on paper.

Fashola Defends Tinubu: Governance Is About Delivery, Not Sainthood

Babatunde Fashola says Nigerians should assess Tinubu's electricity promise by what they experience at home, making a fresh case for the President's second term in 2027.

SEC Delays Approval of Dangote Refinery Share Allocation

Dangote Refinery's share offer attracted ₦5.85 trillion in applications for 4.1 billion available shares. SEC is reviewing the allocation before approving trading.

Akeem Busari Nominated for CAF Women’s Coach of the Year

Akeem Busari has earned a CAF Women's Coach of the Year nomination after guiding Nigeria's Flamingos to their historic first FIFA Under-17 Women's World Cup title in Morocco.